Thursday 6 November 2008

Raikwa of the Cart - Chandogya IV 1 & 2

I've done a fairly free translation here, as the key thing is the story. It's a kind of fairy tale, but with a lot to consider. The story is the first in section IV of the Upanishad; there are more like this to follow, but none perhaps so unusual.

Once upon a time there was a descendant of Jaanashruta, the grandson of his son, who offered gifts respectfully, gave alms in plenty, and fed many. He had rest-houses built everywhere, with the thought, "I will feed the people everywhere". He was called Jaanashruti Pautraayana.

Then once, two swans came flying in the night to where Jaanashruti slept. He woke up when he heard their wings, and was astonished to hear them speak. This is what they said.

The first swan spoke mockingly to the other, "You are far-sighted indeed! Do you not see how the lustrous fame of Jaanashruti spreads everywhere like the light of heaven. Don't touch it - it will burn you!"
The second replied, as quick as anything, "What, who is this individual you are speaking about, as though he were the equal of Raikwa of the Cart?" The first said, "Who is this Raikwa of the Cart?"
"Just as in a game of dice, the highest throw wins over all the others, so all virtuous deeds people may do are outdone by Raikwa. Only someone who knows what Raikwa knows, is like Raikwa. That is who I am talking about."

Jaanashruti overheard this conversation, and as soon as he got up the next morning, he spoke to his charioteer bitterly. "You have praised me in the past, as though I were the equal of Raikwa of the Cart". The charioteer asked in surprise, "What kind of a man is this Raikwa of the Cart?" And Jaanashruti repeated what the swan had said: "Just as in a game of dice, the highest throw wins over all the others, so all virtuous deeds people may do are outdone by Raikwa. Only someone who knows what Raikwa knows, is like Raikwa. That is who I am talking about."

The charioteer was ordered by the king to search everywhere for the great Raikwa, and he searched through all the towns and villages for a king or nobleman of this name. He returned without success. When he reported this to the king, he was told: "Then look for him in the places that a holy man would live!" The charioteer wandered through the forests and lonely places, but nowhere could he find Raikwa.

At last he sat down, discouraged and worn-out, leaning against an old cartwheel, and next to him he saw a man, lying underneath the cart, busy scratching himself. The charioteer was amazed, and said, "Are you, Sir, Raikwa of the Cart?" The man replied, "I am indeed", and having heard that the charioteer returned to tell the king what he had found.

Jaanashruti Pautraayana gathered six hundred head of cattle, a gold necklace, a chariot drawn by she-mules, and travelled to the place.
"O Raikwa!" he said, "Here are six hundred heads of cattle, a fine gold necklace, and a chariot drawn by she-mules. Sir, please teach me about that deity on whom you meditate."
But Raikwa was unimpressed at this offer, and replied scornfully: "Peasant! Keep your chariot, necklace and cows!"

Jaanashruti returned once more, this time with a thousand head of cattle, a gold necklace, a chariot drawn by she-mules, and his daughter. He offered all this to Raikwa, together with the village where he lived, asking once more, "please teach me, Sir".
Gazing on Jaanashruti's daughter's face, Raikwa said, "Well, peasant, you have brought these; and through this very face you will make me speak". And to him he imparted his knowledge.

Chandogya IV, I-II

The king has to give what is most precious to him to get the knowledge.  Raikwa is neither a brahmana nor a kshatriya, nor does he do good deeds like the king, but his knowledge ("the deity on whom you meditate") is more valuable than anything.  Also interesting is the role of the daughter: the feminine is what brings the secret knowledge into the open.

6 comments:

DylanB said...

I've had to interpolate a few bits and pieces to the story to help it make sense. For example when the swans come flying in the night, I've tried to suggest that this could be a dream or a vision. Jaanashruti's conscience is telling him that there is something more he has to know. When the charioteer goes out to look for Raikwa, again there is some embellishment but I think it's true to the spirit of the original that we are meant to see that Raikwa is not where he is expected to be. The whole point about him and his knowledge is that it doesn't conform to expectations, and it can't be bought with common currency.

The whole thing is like a Grimm Brothers fairy tale, but with secret teaching (Upanishad) as the treasure sought.

DylanB said...

I was reflecting on this passage again and I think its earthiness is surprising.

Raikwa is presented as a somewhat coarse individual - 'scratching himself' beneath a cart - and he is won over when the king offers his daughter. "With this face you have made me speak", he says. I'm not aware of any other Upanishadic sages that have to be plied with marriage prospects.

I don't have an answer to why it is like this, but there are affinities with the story following soon after about Satyakaama, whose mother may have been a (low caste) prostitute.

janine said...

Something which strikes me as particularly interesting about this story is that, although discovering what Raikva knows is clearly of central importance, at the end of the story we (unlike Janasruti Pautrayana) still only know THAT he knows – not WHAT he knows. And, instead of leading to an exposition of Raikva’s knowledge, many aspects of the story (such as the contrast between how Raikva is portrayed and how what he knows is described) seem to maintain, perpetuate and make more compelling the question ‘What does Raikva know?’ rather than attempting to answer it.

veer said...

this is clearly discrimination between Bramhan and Shudra as Raikwa calling the king peasant again and again. Raikwa is with secret knowledge suggests he is Bramhan (priest) and king is so generous and well-known for his good deeds thats why he is lustrous but lack of knowledge means 'Veda'. though Bramhan is scratching himself mean suffering from diseases. He is unmarried too. This story is about the superiority and pretensions of Bramhan.

Aditya Ananda said...

Sudra means one who suchati...शोकं आद्रवति इति शुद्रः।

One who follows his sorrows is sudra

Aditya Ananda said...

Sudra means one who follows behind his sorrows
शोकं आद्रवति इति शुद्रः